Proposition 11.

Ratios which are the same with the same ratio are also the same with one another.


For, as A is to B, so let C be to D,

and, as C is to D, so let E be to F;

I say that, as A is to B, so is E to F.

For of A, C, E let equimultiples G, H, K be taken,

and of B, D, F other, chance, equimultiples L, M, N.

Then since, as A is to B, so is C to D,

and of A, C equimultiples G, H have been taken, and of B, D other, chance, equimultiples L, M, therefore, if G is in excess of L, H is also in excess of M, if equal, equal, and if less, less.

Again, since, as C is to D, so is E to F

and of C, E equimultiples H, K have been taken, and of D, F other, chance, equimultiples M, N, therefore, if H is in excess of M, K is also in excess of N, if equal, equal, and if less, less.

But we saw that, if H was in excess of M, G was also in excess of L; if equal, equal; and if less, less;

so that, in addition, if G is in excess of L, K is also in excess of N, if equal, equal, and if less, less.

And G, K are equimultiples of A, E, while L, N are other, chance, equimultiples of B, F; therefore, as A is to B, so is E to F.

Therefore etc.

Q.E.D


Ralph H. Abraham, 28 April, 1996.